Five Common Myths about Hydroponic Fodder – Busted!
India’s dairy sector is the largest in the world . Yet, a silent crisis runs through this backbone of rural livelihoods: fodder scarcity. But unfounded myths about one of the most effective means of combating this scarcity proves to be counter-productive.
India is — home to over 300 million cows and buffaloes and more than 80 million smallholder farmers. Across the country, most dairy farmers depend on crop residues like wheat bhusa or paddy straw and whatever green fodder they can find during the season. But these feeds are often low in nutrition, inconsistent in quality, and expensive during lean periods. This leads to poor milk yields, undernourished animals, and unstable incomes.
Shunya’s Nutri Ankurit Feed (hydroponically grown green fodder), sprouted grain grown in controlled environments without soil, is emerging as a powerful solution to this challenge. It’s nutrient-rich, water-efficient, and can be produced year-round. But as with any new approach, it faces skepticism and misconceptions.
At Shunya Agritech, we’ve worked with >2,500 farmers across 40 villages, and we’ve heard these questions and doubts directly. Let’s tackle some of the most common myths head-on.
Myth 1: Hydroponic fodder is too expensive for small farmers
Reality: In practice, hydroponic fodder is often more economical than what farmers already spend — especially when you factor in hidden costs.
Most small dairy farmers buy dry fodder or green chaff daily from local traders. Prices fluctuate with the season, quality is unreliable, and transportation often adds a hidden markup. During summer, scarcity pushes prices up by 30–40%. Farmers end up paying ₹8–12 per kg for inconsistent feed.
Shunya’s hydroponic sprouted grain fodder is:
- Nutritionally richer, meaning animals require less to meet dietary needs.
- Delivered to their doorstep, saving time and transport costs.
- Price-stable, since it’s grown locally and not tied to monsoon variability.
Farmers who have shifted to daily subscriptions have found their per-liter cost of milk production reduced, even though per kg price may look similar. That’s because better nutrition yields more milk per cow — the real economic lever.
Case in point: Uttam, a smallholder from Kohra, started with a 5 kg/day trial. Within three months, his average milk yield per cow increased by 15–20%. The cost of fodder didn’t rise — but his income did.
Myth 2: Hydroponics is only for large commercial farms
Reality: This myth stems from how hydroponic farming entered India — through expensive, imported greenhouse systems. But the model has evolved dramatically.
Today, farmers don’t need to own sophisticated equipment or invest in climate-controlled polyhouses. Shunya’s Growth & Logistics Centres (GLCs) do the production. Farmers simply subscribe to daily fodder delivery in quantities that match their herd size.
- 85% of our farmer customers own 2–5 animals.
- The minimum subscription starts as low as 5 kg per day.
- Deliveries are made directly to their village, just like daily milk collection runs in reverse.
This distributed model makes hydroponic fodder accessible to small and marginal farmers — the real backbone of India’s dairy economy.
Myth 3: Hydroponic systems can’t work in India’s climate
Reality: This is a fair concern. Imported vertical farming systems often struggle with India’s high humidity, heat, and dust, leading to fungal growth and poor yield.
But at Shunya, we’ve spent the last two years engineering India-centric solutions:
- Our Viksit growth system uses root-based water flow instead of top spraying, cutting down infection spread.
- We use longer trays with inlet–outlet water channels, improving irrigation coverage while saving up to 90% water compared to conventional methods.
- Controlled airflow and strict cleaning protocols keep fungal infestation at bay.
- IoT-based sensors and alerts help our teams monitor and correct deviations before they impact quality.
The result is reliable daily production even in the peak of North Indian summers — something imported systems often can’t guarantee.
Myth 4: It’s just another version of ordinary fodder
Reality: This is one of the most common misunderstandings. Sprouted grain fodder is not just another type of bhusa or chopped green. It’s a different nutritional profile altogether.
When grains like maize are sprouted for 7–10 days:
- Enzymes are activated, breaking down complex starches into easily digestible sugars.
- Crude protein levels increase, improving digestibility.
- Moisture content rises to 80–85%, improving hydration for animals.
- Vitamins like A, E, and B-complex increase naturally.
For the animal, this means:
- Better digestion and feed conversion
- Improved body condition and fertility
- Higher milk yield and fat content
Farmers often report seeing a visible improvement in animal energy and coat shine within weeks of regular feeding.
In short — it’s not more of the same; it’s better.
Myth 5: It’s too complicated to manage
Reality: With older hydroponic setups, farmers had to manage irrigation, cleanliness, and environmental conditions themselves. That did make it complicated.
But with the Fodder-as-a-Service model, Shunya takes on all the complexity:
- Farmers don’t need to grow fodder.
- We handle production, quality control, and delivery.
- Farmers simply feed their animals — just as they do today.
Our GLC teams follow standard operating procedures supported by the SMART VIDHI platform. Farmers don’t have to invest time or energy learning new technology.
And for entrepreneurs who choose to become production partners, we provide technical training, financing support, and operational SOPs, along with simple to use technology tools so they can run centres profitably without needing deep agri-tech expertise.
Why These Myths Persist — and Why It’s Changing Now
New technologies often meet skepticism. Farmers have good reason to be cautious: they’ve seen plenty of overhyped solutions that fail in the field.
Hydroponics in India had a rocky start — often sold as an expensive, shiny greenhouse system with little local adaptation. Those early failures seeded many of today’s myths.
But three things have changed:
- Localization: Systems like Shunya’s Viksit structure are engineered for Indian conditions — heat, dust, humidity and all.
- Business Model: Farmers no longer need to own the system. They can simply subscribe like they would for milk collection.
- Proof on the Ground: With thousands of farmers already using the service, the results are visible — healthier animals, better yields, and stable pricing.
Real-World Results Speak Louder Than Claims
In the last 10 months:
- 2,500+ farmers have subscribed to Shunya’s fodder service.
- Daily production across 4 centres averages 1.8 MT/day.
- Farmers report up to 33% increase in income, mainly from improved milk yields.
- We’ve saved 100+ acres of land and 40 million liters of water through hydroponic production.
- Greenhouse gas emissions have the potential to reduce by 15%, thanks to better feed efficiency.
These numbers aren’t theoretical — they come from real villages in Uttar Pradesh and Haryana.
The Road Ahead: From Myth to Mainstream
India’s dairy sector is at an inflection point. Fodder availability has always been treated as a local, informal challenge — but it’s actually a massive, system-level opportunity.
Hydroponic sprouted fodder is not a silver bullet. But it is a powerful tool — one that’s finally maturing beyond myth.
- For farmers, it means stable, affordable access to quality nutrition year-round.
- For entrepreneurs, it’s a chance to build sustainable rural enterprises as Production Partners.
- For the planet, it means reduced land pressure, water savings, and lower emissions.
Every new technology needs early believers. As more farmers adopt hydroponic fodder and see the results for themselves, the myths will naturally fade — replaced by trust, proof, and prosperity.
In Conclusion
When Babulalji from Ghatampur first saw sprouted fodder, he thought: “Yeh hamare gaon mein kaise chalega?”
Three months later, he’s a regular subscriber — and a believer.
Technology adoption in rural India doesn’t happen in headlines. It happens quietly, one farmer at a time.
Hydroponic fodder is no longer a futuristic concept. It’s on the ground, in villages, feeding cows and powering livelihoods.
The myths are real — but so is the proof. And the proof is growing, one tray at a time.
Shunya’s Nutri Ankurit Feed is a Fodder-as-a-Service for dairy farmers wherein they dont need to invest in hydroponics setup and can get fresh fodder delivered near home daily through an on-demand hydroponic delivery service in India.
About Shunya Agritech
Shunya Agritech is a leading Fodder-as-a-Service provider building the future of dairy through innovation in hydroponic fodder in India. We grow and deliver affordable hydroponic fodder for small farmers, ensuring a year-round green fodder supply in India—regardless of season or geography. Our proprietary Nutri Ankurit Feed (NAF), grown using vertical farming for fodder, reaches farmers daily through a robust green fodder delivery network. Shunya’s hydroponic fodder delivery in India helps solve deep-rooted issues of nutrition, cost, and availability. Through our digital veterinary services in rural India, we also provide remote veterinary consultations for livestock, connecting farmers to expert care at the tap of a button. With our expanding network of Growth and Logistics Centres (GLC) and franchise-ready models, Shunya empowers communities, enhances milk productivity, and drives sustainable growth—one farm at a time.
Follow Shunya Agritech on Linkedin, X, Facebook & Instagram for regular updates. Subscribe to our Youtube Channel.
